diff --git a/lemur/notifications/cli.py b/lemur/notifications/cli.py
index 0a76bad5..042a54fb 100644
--- a/lemur/notifications/cli.py
+++ b/lemur/notifications/cli.py
@@ -85,10 +85,12 @@ def security_expiration_summary(exclude):
     status = FAILURE_METRIC_STATUS
     try:
         print("Starting to notify security team about expiring certificates!")
-        status = send_security_expiration_summary(exclude)
+        success = send_security_expiration_summary(exclude)
         print(
-            "Finished notifying security team about expiring certificates!"
+            f"Finished notifying security team about expiring certificates! Success: {success}"
         )
+        if success:
+            status = SUCCESS_METRIC_STATUS
     except Exception:
         sentry.captureException()